Sablefish
farmer has a vision that fishermen don't like
The Vancouver Sun
Wed 25 Aug 2004
Section: BusinessBC
Byline: Don Whiteley
Gus Angus is a fish farmer with a vision.
His farming operation in Jervis Inlet, just west of Egmont,
has been in business since 1977 -- first farming oysters and
then, starting in 1977, Pacific (not Atlantic) salmon species.
He and some of his colleagues are in the final
stages of negotiations to have a set of organic food standards
applied to the industry, and it's Angus' intention to gain
organic certification for his farming operations once those
standards are in place.
Hardly the kind of guy you'd think might draw
the concentrated ire of environmentalists and fishermen --
but he is Target No. 1 at the moment.
Angus runs the only B.C. farming operation that has been producing,
on a commercial basis, farmed sablefish. He's been doing this
for the last four years, and will happily talk your ear off
about the potential for this particular fish to revolutionize
farming on the B.C. coast.
And that's why he's in the spotlight. The
Canadian Sablefish Association, which represents a small group
of B.C. fishermen who specialize in catching wild sablefish
(90 per cent of which goes to Japan), is pulling out all the
stops to blow this nascent industry out of the water.
The association argues strenuously that not
enough is known about the environmental impact of sablefish
farming. Their concern is that, while Angus is the only fish
farmer in commercial production, more than 40 other B.C. fish
farmers have a sablefish component in their farming licences.
The CSA emphasizes the environmental aspects
of their campaign. But the real risk, should a farmed sablefish
business prosper on the B.C. coast, is that the currently
very lucrative wild fishery will experience significant price
erosion as a result of the farmed competition.
At the moment, the annual wild harvest of
B.C. sablefish averages 3,000 tonnes (the 2004 allotment is
4,500 tonnes), while the Alaskans take a much bigger haul,
at more than 20,000 tonnes.
Pacific sablefish, or rock cod, is unique
to the Pacific Northwest, living in the waters between Washington
and Alaska. It exists nowhere else. It is an oily whitefish
much in demand in Japan -- but almost totally unknown in North
America and Europe. Angus is slowly developing a North American
market for his small --1,200 pounds per week -- production
and you can find it on the menus in such high-end places as
the Chateau Lake Louise and the Banff Springs Hotel.
A report done for the B.C. government in 2001
outlines a large potential market for farmed sablefish, up
to 16,000
tonnes by the year 2021, and it says some of
that farmed supply will displace wild fish as stocks decline.
The report suggests that wholesale revenues from a sablefish
industry could reach $114 million by 2021, compared with the
current $30 million annually from the wild fishery.
"I think it could easily become B.C.'s
most important species," says Angus. "There's so
much salmon produced in the world that salmon farmers here
haven't made any money. But no one else in the world has black
cod."
Dr. Gidon Minkoff runs SableFin Hatcheries
on Saltspring Island. His is the only sablefish hatchery,
and expects in five years' time to produce about two million
juvenile fish a year for farming operations such as Angus',
and Minkoff too sees the potential for significant growth.
"There's huge potential there,"
he says. "Generally, the big white chunky fish are disappearing
off the table. Atlantic cod is decimated; North Sea cod is
near total shutdown; the large hake fisheries in Ireland are
gone; and Chilean sea bass has been overfished. Black cod
[sablefish] can fill some of that."
But not if the Canadian Sablefish Association
has its way. In the early days of developing the concept of
sablefish farming, a number of the association's members actually
entertained the idea of participating in the venture.
But after a stormy parting of the ways, the
association now has its sights set on stopping it dead in
its tracks. The CSA has applied for (and been granted) a judicial
review of a federal Department of Fisheries and Oceans decision
to approve the transfer of juvenile fish from SableFin Hatcheries
to Angus' fish farm.
They also sought in July (but were turned
down) an interim injunction halting the transfer of this year's
juvenile sablefish to the fish farm.
The full review is expected to take place
in the spring. The CSA wants further transfers halted on the
basis that they could do irreparable harm to their wild fish
stocks.
"They haven't slowed us down at all,"
says Minkoff. "They also tried to stop us from obtaining
permits to get wild brood stock that we need. They've fought
us every step of the way. They objected to regional health
authorities that we were going to use domestic septic systems
for fish wastes; they tried to stop us getting a subdivision
application, [and] a waste management permit. They appealed
every permit we've ever received."
And now, to help with their cause, they are
apparently enlisting support from Alaska. That's no surprise,
given that Alaska has banned all forms of fish farming and
opted instead to do fish ranching, in which juveniles raised
in the hatchery are allowed to disperse into the ocean rather
than kept in net pens. Alaska would love to see any competition
from B.C. held in check.
Click here to read our reply.
|